A discussion on the trial of tom robinson on rape accusations in maycomb alabama

View Full Essay Words: As the focus of the movie was on right and wrong, the director of this film, obert Mulligan, provided the American movie viewing public with a strong lesson in justice but he was also able, largely through the character of Atticus Finch, to demonstrate that humanity can still prevail even under difficult circumstances. Mulligan could have soften the message and still have captured the essence of the book upon which the movie was based but, instead, Mulligan made a deliberate statement in the way that he portrayed the characters in the story and how the movie told the story.

Heck Tate is the first witness. Under cross-examination, he admits that a doctor was never called to the scene to examine Mayella Ewell. Bob Ewell takes the stand next and causes a stir in the courtroom with his bad attitude and foul language.

Ewell is not shaken from his story, but Atticus carefully plants the seed that Mr.

A discussion on the trial of tom robinson on rape accusations in maycomb alabama

Ewell himself could've beaten Mayella. Mayella takes the stand next.

Coming of Age in to Kill a Mockingbird Essay Example for Free

Even though Atticus believes that she's lying, he treats her with courtesy and respect; Mayella thinks that he's making fun of her. Her testimony soon proves that Mayella is unused to gentility and common courtesy.

Atticus asks Tom to stand up so that Mayella may identify him; as he does, Scout notices that Tom's left arm is withered and useless — he could not have committed the crime in the way it was described. The state rests its case. Atticus calls only one witness — Tom Robinson. Tom tells the true story, being careful all the while not to come right out and say that Mayella is lying.

However, Tom makes a fatal error when he admits under cross-examination that he, a black man, felt sorry for Mayella Ewell. Dill has a very emotional response to Mr. Gilmer's questioning and leaves the courtroom in tears. Scout follows Dill outside, where they talk with Dolphus Raymond, who reveals the secret behind his brown bag and his drinking.

Scout and Dill return to the courtroom in time to hear the last half of Atticus' impassioned speech to the jury. Just as Atticus finishes, Calpurnia walks into the courtroom and heads toward Atticus. Analysis At this point in the story, readers may be tempted to think that Tom Robinson's trial is basically about white prejudice against African Americans.

Prejudice certainly does come to play in the court proceedings, but Lee explores much deeper human emotions and societal ideals than the straightforward mistreatment of a person based on skin color.

The Ewells are what people today would call "white trash. No truant officers could keep their numerous offspring in school; no public health officer could free them from congenital defects, various worms, and the diseases indigenous to filthy surroundings.

Just beyond their home is a "Negro settlement. The fact is that most in the African American community live cleaner, more honest, and more productive lives than the Ewells.

Consequently, the resentment against blacks on the part of the "white trash" runs deep. Against this backdrop of a trial where a "white-trash" female is accusing a black man of a violent crime, Lee expertly explores several of the novel's major themes while focusing on the questions of prejudice and class or social station.

In Maycomb during the time of Tom Robinson's trial, African Americans reside at the bottom of the totem pole as far as power in the community.

Even Scout, who probably can't yet define the term "prejudice," tells Dill, "'Well, Dill, after all, he's just a Negro. In Scout's world, some things just are, and the fact that blacks are "just Negroes" is one of them. In fact, Scout shows her lack of intentional prejudice by admitting "If he [Tom Robinson] had been whole, he would have been a fine specimen of a man.

If Scout believed that blacks were truly lesser, then her character would have no reason for telling this story — the story she'd tell, if she told one at all, would be markedly different. The blacks in the community accept their lot. They may not like the treatment they receive, but to defy the rules set by the community means literally risking their lives.

Tom Robinson did nothing but help Mayella Ewell. In fact, he "was probably the only person who was ever decent to her. But, for an African American man to publicly admit feeling pity for any white person is overstepping societal bounds. In truth, Tom embarrasses Mayella by refusing her advances and Mayella embarrasses her father by making advances toward a black man.

Bob Ewell's pride can't afford for a black man to go back to his community talking about a white woman making a pass at him.

Worse yet, Tom is now aware of incest in the Ewell household, something that is taboo in every class. Tom was unlikely to tell anyone of what had happened with Mayella, recognizing that his safety was at stake.

A discussion on the trial of tom robinson on rape accusations in maycomb alabama

Bob Ewell could've let the whole thing drop, but he'd rather be responsible for an innocent man's death than risk having his family further diminished in the town's eyes.Tom Robinson is a young black man who is discriminated against by Maycomb citizens because of his skin color, but Scout learns to think differently.

He is accused of raping Mayella Ewell, a . Atticus went to the jail to protect Tom and these men came. They wanted to hurt Tom because of what he supposedly did and because he was black. Scout asks Mr. Cunningham to tell Walter "hey". Both the Scottsboro trials and the Tom Robinson trial were set in s Alabama, a highly segregated society.

Both involved accusations of rape against African American men. By: Sean Joudry Located in the southern United States, is Maycomb, Alabama. In this small town, Tom Robinson, a black man, husband, and father of two is on trial for his life for the crime of rape.

The accuser is Mayella Violet Ewell, the 19 year old daughter of Robert E. Lee Ewell.5/5(2). Tom Robinson is a black man accused of assaulting and raping Mayella Ewell on the evening of November Tom Robinson had offered to help Mayella complete a chore inside her home when she.

Tom Robinson Found Guilty For Rape Tom Robinson, a Negro man, was accused of raping Mayella Ewell, a 19 year old and the daughter of Bob Ewell. The court case took place at the Maycomb County courthouse, and a huge crowd of people, both white and blacks came to watch the trial.

What are some similarities between the Tom Robinson trial and the Scottsboro trial? | eNotes